BS"D
There has been a trendy debate going on in the Jewish world started by a "kiruv" personality stressing that You, Hashem needs us (Your creations) more than we need You. This is a total falsehood and I'm going to defend it.
When You Hashem created the universe, is it something You need? The answer is a resounding No and I'm quoting these sources from "The Handbook of Jewish Thought" compiled by R' Aryeh Kaplan, zt"l, which is a wonderful resource for any Jewish library.
Creation did not fill any need in G-d's being. G-d is inherently perfect, and does not have any need for the universe. -- Yad, Yesodey HaTorah 1:2,3; Moreh Nevuchim 3:13; Emunos v'Deyos 1:4' S'vil Emunah ad loc. 1:4:9; Reishis Chochmah, Shaar HaYirah 1 (8d). Df. Pesikta 6 (57b); Moreh Nevuchim 3:25
In relation to man, the R' Kaplan wrote:
Since G-d is absolutely perfect in Himself, it is obvious that He had no inner need to create the universe. It must therefore be concluded that G-d's creation of the universe was a most perfect act of altruism and love. It is thus written, "Olam Chesed Yiboneh" (Tehillim 89:3) -- A world of kindness will be built (translation).
To fulfill His goal, G-d created the universe as an environment for a creature capable of partaking of His goodness. The creature would be capable of understanding, joy, and happiness, as well as of communing with G-d. This creature is man. -- Mesilas Yesharim 1 (3b); Derech Hashem 1:2:5.
There are those who say:
In short: Hashem is perfect and lacks nothing, but He needs us to do our part in order for Him to fulfill His will to share His goodness with us, which we can only receive fully if we earn it.
I would ask if Hashem "needs" us to do our part, then why would Hashem give each of us bechira (free will) at the same time? Hashem put in place the system of middah-kneged-middah (measure-for-measure) as a response to our free will. There is a consequence to everything be it a mitzvah (positive commandment) or an aveira (sin).
(19) I call heaven and earth to witness against you this day, that I have set before you life and death, the blessing and the curse: therefore choose life, that you may live, you and your seed;
(20) to love Hashem your G-d, to obey his voice, and to cling to him; for He is your life, and the length of your days; that you may dwell in the land which Hashem swore to your fathers, to Avrohom, to Yitzchok, and to Yaakov, to give them. -- Devorim 30:19-20
Hashem did not say, "I NEED you to choose life instead of death...." The choice is ours and Hashem does not force it. There is only one scenario according to the Midrash that we were left with a choice to accept the Torah or die buried under the mountain because the entire world was created on account of the Jews accepting the Torah at Har Sinai. Still, we had the choice and we picked the correct option of life, even under duress.
R' Kaplan writes:
The Torah was created for the sake of Israel. G-d's purpose in creation required that Israel accept the Torah. If not, all creation would have lost its reason for being, and would have ceased to exist. -- Tana D'Vey Eliyahu Rabah 14; Koheles Rabbah 1:9; Sifri on Devorim 11:21. Shabbos 88a; Avodah Zarah 3a; Rashi on Bereishis 1:31
Beginning from Adam HaRishon (the first man), was he needed to perform Hashem's Will? No, because Hashem gave him one and only one mitzvah to exercise his free will, and he did not pass. If Hashem needed Adam to pass, He would have made him like an angel who has no free will. Hashem let the world rot on account of Adam's sin and still maintains it to this day.
R' Kaplan writes:
In order for man to have true free choice, he must not only have inner freedom of will, but also an environment in which a choice between obedience and disobedience exists. -- Derech Hashem 1:2:2; Cf Midrash Tehilim 36:3; Reishis Chochmah, Shaar HaYirah 7 (22b)
R' Miller writes:
Free Will, the Greatest Miracle After Creation
The existence of free will is the greatest miracle after the Creation of the Universe. The Creator, by especial miracle, left a space in which He allows Man to move of his own free will. Outside this space, everything is decreed and foreordained; but in this area, men can choose to do according to their own wishes. No object, or force, or being in all the Universe has any impulse of will of its own choice, except Man.
— Rejoice, O YouthYou have to understand, there's a very important purpose in avodas Hashem. Hashem doesn't need your avodah. He doesn't need you to serve Him. הקב״ה מתאוה לתפלתן צדיקים -- He loves the prayers of tzadikim (Yevamos 64a). Why does He love their prayers? Does He need their prayers? No, they need their prayers.
-- Chumash, Foundations and Principles of Bereishis
Does Hashem now need the Jews to fix the world? Hashem gives the Jews the opportunity to fix the world, but He does not need or depend on us because of the system He put in place. We should want to fix the world and perform Hashem's Will because that is the truth and we need it therefore we should want it. (Devorim 30:19-20)
Sometimes Hashem interferes with our bechira for the benefit of the entire Klal Yisroel. For instance, Hashem asked Moshe to request the Jews to "borrow" items from their Egyptian neighbors such as gold and silver and clothing before they departed Egypt so as to appease Avrohom Avinu that the Jews would leave Egypt in great wealth as He promised Avrohom.
(2) Now, speak in the hearing of the people, and each man shall ask of his fellow, and every woman of her fellow, silver vessels and gold vessels." -- Parashas Bo 11:2
Rashi: 2) דבר נא PLEASE SPEAK – The word נא is always an expression of entreaty. Here it means: I entreat you, warn them about this which follows, so that righteous man, their father, may not say: the prophecy "they shall serve them, and they shall afflict them" (Bereshis 15:13) He fulfilled in them, but the promise "and afterwards they shall go out with great property" (Bereshis 15:14) He did not fulfill (Brochos 9a-b).
Does Hashem need Moshe to do these things? I don't think so. Hashem has many agents to do His Will, if Moshe refused. And there will be consequences as we have learned when Moshe refused to be the messenger to Paroh arguing with Hashem for seven days. Moshe's final argument was that his older brother, Aharon, should be the chosen one and not him. The consequence of that was Moshe lost his chance for kehunah (priesthood) and remained a Levi, while his brother Aharon was inducted into the kehunah. Does Hashem need Moshe to do His Will? You tell me. The answer is No.
In another episode with the Mei Merivah (Waters of Strife), Moshe did not perform Hashem's Will. Moshe struck the rock instead of speaking to it, making a Chillul Hashem (defamation of Hashem's Name). For that, Moshe was banned from entering Eretz Yisroel (the Land of Israel). The Torah is not shy to point out mistakes made by our Avos (forefathers) and the point is to make us aware that our Avos are not infallible (learned from my Rov).
There is a powerful concept from the Gemara that says like this:
“B’derech she’hadom rotzeh leileich molichin oso – In the way a person wants to go, Hashem leads him.” Makkos [10b]
The above is in sync with what we know as bechirah. Hashem does not interfere with our power to choose to serve Him or not, to go along or against His Will. Therefore it cannot be that He "needs" us to perform His will.
When it comes to the final geulah (redemption), there is a concept of "b'itah vs achishenah". Does Hashem need the Jews to bring Moshiach? No, because Hashem can bring Moshiach either way -- at its time (b'itah) if the Jews fail to do teshuva (return to Hashem) after our allotment of time is up or Hashem will speed up the redemption (achishenah) if all the Jews around the world decide to complete their teshuva before the allotment of time is up.
Why didn't Mordechai tell Esther, "Hashem NEEDS YOU to do this!". Instead, Mordechai said:
(13) Mordechai said to reply to Esther, "Do not imagine to yourself that you shall escape in the king's house more than all the Judeans.
(14) For, if you will indeed remain silent at this time, relief and salvation will arise for the Judeans from another place ...
So, we learn from these examples in Tanach and Gemara that Hashem does not need the Jews for anything because of the system of bechirah and middah-kneged-middah. The power of free will is so great that Hashem does not want to interfere unless it's urgent and for the benefit of the Jews.
Before the sin, Adam was capable of discerning between emes (truth) and sheker (falsehood).
Since everything exists only by virtue of G-d's Will, it follows that what He rejects has no true existence. Good is what He desires, and therefore only good can be called true and real. Adam, before the sin, saw this so clearly that he saw the whole world only in terms of truth and falsehood. What G-d wanted was true, and what G-d did not want was false and unreal. -- Rav Eliyahu Dessler "Strive For Truth" Bereishis
After the sin, everything became blurry and we still live in the after-effects of Adam's sin that has been going on for almost 6000 years. There is something that I always follow. If something new and trendy appears later in the generation that conflicts with what we already know as the truth -- take it with a grain of salt and lookup the sources.
Hashem does NOT change. He won't suddenly at the end of times switch gears and say that He NEEDS US now more than ever. From R' Kaplan:
G-d Himself is therefore absolutely unchangeable and unchanging. He thus said, "I am G-d, I do not change." (Malachi 3:6) -- Yad, Yesodey HaTorah 1:10,11; Moreh Nevuchim 1:11
There is nothing new under the sun. There will always be false "prophets" preaching falsehood and we see more and more of this at the end of days. How lucky are those who can recognize the falsehood.
The verdict: Hashem does not need us for anything. Period.
Thank You Hashem for allowing me this opportunity to defend the emes, Your emes.

Comments
Post a Comment